Opportunity, Montana: Big Copper, Bad Water, and the Burial of an American Landscape - a review

Brad Tyer's debut book Opportunity, Montana: Big Copper, Bad Water, and the Burial of an American Landscape is a must read for anyone involved in stream restoration and conservation - at any level.

The book does a great job chronicling the rise of the Copper Kings, the history of Milltown, Opportunity, Anaconda, and Butte and the brutal treatment and destruction of the Clark Fork River watershed in the name of progress and profit.  Tyer also archives the lead-up and movement to remove Milltown Dam which held back millions of cubic yards of toxic, metal laden sediments.

Interwoven perfectly into the discoveries Tyer makes regarding the Clark Fork Restoration Project, is a touching story regarding the relationship he has had with his late father.  I am a stream restoration guy who has spent most of my professional career working on some aspect of this project.  More than one person Tyer interviews in the book has been my boss at some time.  I have done it all with the backdrop of a shitty relationship with my father.  It was like Tyer wrote this book for me personally!

The heart of the book revolves around the case of environmental injustice Tyer makes for the town of Opportunity, MT.  This tiny "town" is centered in the middle of a sea of toxic mine waste dumps called "tailings ponds."  Google Earth Opportunity, MT to get an idea of the scale of this mess!  When Milltown Dam was removed, the toxic sediment needed to go somewhere and Tyer highlights the decision making process which led to Opporunity paying the price for Missoula's restored river. 

Brad Tyer's writing carries you swiftly through a lot of history and litigation which is no easy task.  I found that his slight sarcasm, use of some great quotes, and a little bit of snark to be the perfect way to hear some of these stories that I was already pretty familiar with.  This book is a treasure trove of history and research and is a great resource to have on the bookshelf after you've read it.

I did find a couple of irrelevant errors in the text.  The book gets some minor technicalities wrong like the location of the mouth of Blacktail Creek and it also says that brown trout are native to MT, which they're certainly not.  These minor details have no effect on the story but did make me a bit nuts when I came across them.

The Opportunity, Montana blog provides many national reviews and stories from brad from the lead-up to the book release last fall.  Check it out for more info on the project, the town, and a bunch of great pics.

Book tease: Opportunity, Montana - Big Copper, Bad Water, and the Burial of an American Landscape

I am halfway through this great book about the Clark Fork's obliteration due to 100 years of industrial scale mining. Today, I came a cross a great quote that I wanted to share. There are many analogies which seek to make this same point however, this one is my favorite:

"I tend not to trust extremist and ideologues.  It's not about preferring the middle of the road, it's that 'road' is too rigid a metaphor.  On a river, you can't afford to hug strictly the right or left bank and still hope to arrive downstream. You have to follow the current where it leads, left, right, or center.  Sometimes you have to get out and walk."

Eroded banks comprised of toxic mine waste below Warm Springs, MT

Mine waste stream bank